Learn about Sicily Coal Fired Pizza, our chefs, seasonal cuisine, craft bar program, and the family behind one of Middletown's favorite restaurants.

About Sicily Coal Fired Pizza | Middletown, CT

About

Contact Sicily Coal Fired Pizza for reservations, private events, live music, hours, and dining information in Middletown, CT.

Contact Sicily Coal Fired Pizza | Middletown, CT

Contact

Browse photos of Sicily's coal fired pizza, handcrafted cocktails, private events, live entertainment, and vibrant dining experience.

Restaurant & Food Gallery | Sicily Middletown

Gallery

See upcoming live music, social hour specials, and special events at Sicily Coal Fired Pizza in Middletown, CT. Plan your next night out.

Upcoming Events in Middletown, CT | Sicily

Upcoming Events

Enjoy New Haven-style coal fired pizza, handmade pasta, craft cocktails, live music, and 72 wines by the glass at Sicily in Middletown, CT.

Coal Fired Pizza in Middletown, CT | Sicily

Home

Explore Sicily's seasonal menu featuring coal fired pizza, fresh pasta, seafood, steaks, raw bar favorites, craft cocktails, and more.

Seasonal Italian Menu in Middletown, CT | Sicily

Press & Media | Sicily Coal Fired Pizza

Press

Host private events at Sicily in Middletown, CT. Perfect for birthdays, showers, corporate events, rehearsal dinners, and celebrations.

Private Events in Middletown, CT | Sicily

Private Events

Discover 72 wines by the glass, over 400 curated bottles, and Sicily's exclusive Coravin wine experience in Middletown, CT.

Wine Bar in Middletown, CT | The Wine Bar @ Sicily

Wine Bar

Sicily Coal Fired Pizza

Add Ons

Photos

Summers with the Radio 

Drinks

Food

Experience

Shouts

Middletown

menu-pagehero

homepage-slider7

homepage-slider15

gallery-pagehero

contact-pagehero

homepage-slider5

homepage-slider11

about-pagehero

homepage-slider9

homepage-slider16

homepage-slider8

homepage-slider1

private-events-contact

homepage-slider19

homepage-slider12

homepage-slider17

homepage-slider4

homepage-slider6

homepage-slider2

events-pagehero

homepage-slider3

homepage-slider13

homepage-slider10

homepage-slider18

homepage-slider14

private-events-pagehero

wine-bar-pagehero

VILNAA0051T01 (1).jpg

The Wine Bar at Sicily invites you to explore an unparalleled wine experience in the heart of 412 Main St Middletown. This space can accommodate a minimum of 50 guests and a max of 80 guests. We rent out the Wine Bar room for private events Sunday-Thursday with a $2,000 room charge & Fridays & Saturdays with a $5,000 room charge. Our wine bar offers an impressive selection of 72 wines by the glass, allowing you to savor a diverse range of flavors, from rare vintages to modern favorites. With over 400 different wines sourced from renowned vineyards across the globe, our collection is meticulously curated to satisfy both the connoisseur and the curious palate. Our state-of-the-art Coravin wine preservation system ensures that every glass is served at the perfect temperature, preserving the integrity and richness of each wine. Whether you’re exploring new varietals or indulging in your go-to favorites, The Wine Bar at Sicily promises an extraordinary journey through the world of wine. The Wine Bar opens everyday at 5:00pm Reservations are available for parties of two & up! Hours: Sunday-Wednesday 5pm-11pm and Thursday-Saturday 5pm-12am

THE WINE BAR

site_private-events_sidebyside_6

Step into a world of timeless charm with our exclusive Speakeasy room, available for private events. Ideal for gatherings of 30 to 40 guests, this intimate space offers a quieter, more refined setting with its own private bar. Whether you’re planning a sophisticated soirée or a relaxed get-together, the Speakeasy sets the perfect tone for an unforgettable evening.

Speakeasy

site_private-events_sidebyside_5

The Lounge at Sicily Coal Fired Pizza is a spacious and elegant event space available for rent Sunday through Wednesday. The room charge for the Lounge is $1,000.00. It can accommodate a minimum of 60 guests and a maximum of 200 guests, with a seating capacity of 80 guests for sit-down events. The lounge is decorated with modern, elegant decor and features comfortable lounge couches & high top seating's, creating a mingling & social atmosphere for your guests to enjoy. The room also offers a private bar where guests can enjoy signature cocktails and a wide selection of wine and beer. Food service in the Lounge is only available in buffet style, allowing guests to sample a variety of delicious dishes from Sicily Coal Fired Pizza's private menu. From appetizers to entrees, the buffet style service provides guests with a wide range of options to suit any taste.

The Lounge

site_private-events_sidebyside_4

The Board Room at Sicily Coal Fired Pizza is a private event space that can accommodate a minimum of 30 guests and a maximum of 40 guests. The room is great for hosting a variety of events such as birthday parties, family gatherings and other special occasions. With its cozy and intimate atmosphere, the Board Room is an ideal place for groups to gather and enjoy delicious pizza and drinks. The room is equipped with comfortable seating, making it perfect for family style dining and casual gatherings.

The Board Room

site_private-events_sidebyside_3

The Cellar room at Sicily is the perfect setting for private events and parties. With its own bar that can accommodate some seating. The room is designed with a formal atmosphere. It can accommodate a minimum of 40 guests and a maximum of 100 guests and sit down 75 guests, making it the ideal space for any occasion. Additionally, The Cellar has its own bathrooms, which provides an added level of convenience and privacy for your guests. Whether you're hosting a business event, a birthday party, or a special celebration, The Cellar room is the perfect choice.

cella rroom.jpeg

site_private-events_sidebyside_2

THE CELLAR ROOM

CHOOSE YOUR SPACE

site_private-events_content_1

Five Unique Rooms. Endless Possibilities.

From intimate gatherings to large-scale celebrations, Sicily offers a collection of distinctive private event spaces where elevated hospitality, unforgettable atmosphere, and exceptional dining come together for every occasion.

Private Events Menu

Celebrate In Signature Sicily Style

DSC02498.jpg

press-pagehero

8e43c06c-6e20-4e17-84ca-7af3f47672a1.jpeg

site_wine-bar_parallax_2

Our state-of-the-art Coravin wine preservation system ensures that every glass is served at the perfect temperature, preserving the integrity and richness of each wine. Whether you’re exploring new varietals or indulging in your go-to favorites, The Wine Bar at Sicily promises an extraordinary journey through the world of wine. The Wine Bar opens everyday at 5:00pm Reservations are available for parties of two & up!

DSC02515 (1).jpg

site_wine-bar_sidebyside_1

Every Pour, Perfectly Preserved

The Wine Bar at Sicily invites you to explore an unparalleled wine experience in the heart of 412 Main St Middletown. We are proudly the only restaurant in CT that offers an impressive selection of 72 wines by the glass by our state of the art Coravin wine preservation system, allowing you to savor a diverse range of flavors, from rare vintages to modern favorites. With over 400 different wines sourced from renowned vineyards across the globe, our collection is meticulously curated to satisfy both the connoisseur and the curious palate.

site_wine-bar_content_0

Rare Pours, Global Vineyards & One of Connecticut’s Most Unique Wine Experiences

A World of Wine Awaits

50b58265-dabb-40e2-96c6-71ba43053185.webp

5f3af9dd-7d49-4804-be51-3b4d1046e544.jpeg

upcoming-events-pagehero

site_about_imagegrid_2

Chef Zachary Anderson’s culinary path began long before his professional training, rooted in the time spent learning the craft alongside his father. He later formalized this passion at Johnson & Wales University, earning degrees in both Culinary Arts and Food Service Management Today, Zachary is a seasoned industry leader with over a decade of experience navigating the fast-paced demands of high-volume, scratch kitchens. Having held key leadership roles at Hard Rock Café Foxwoods, Hash House A Go Go, and Guy Fieri’s Foxwoods Kitchen + Bar, he has mastered the art of balancing bold, seasonal flavors with meticulous operational oversight. Known for his hands-on leadership and commitment to quality, Chef Zachary consistently delivers an elevated dining experience built on technical skill and a lifelong love for the kitchen.

DSC02645.jpg

site_about_sidebyside_1

A Lifelong Passion for Elevated Italian Dining

Meet Our Chef

Tony and Maria Prifitera built their dream restaurant to allow guests to have an upbeat dining experience. Sicily brings the New Haven tradition of coal fired oven pizza to Middletown Connecticut, plus freshly made pastas, baked breads and locally sourced products. Our bars feature over 50 beers on tap, craft cocktails, a great selection of wines and Happy Hour Specials Monday through Friday from 3:00 to 6:00. Sicily is comprised of a roomy dining room and bar, an upstairs lounge with entertainment and a downstairs function room that is available for private events for 30 to 125 guests. The menu encompasses New Haven-Style Pizza, Pasta, Steaks, Veal, Chicken, Seafood and Appetizers including a Charcuterie board, Octopus, Eggplant frites, and items made with Liuzzi cheeses of New Haven. Our team is made up of Executive Chef Zach Anderson, Pastry Chef Liliana Orleanu, Bar Manager Melissa (Misia) Daniel, General Managers Sabrina Prifitera & Sal Font, Front of the House Managers Joe Prifitera & Rachel Ambrose. Melissa (Misia) Daniel assembled a varied seasonal cocktail menu, wine list, and 50 beers on tap featuring many local breweries.

site_about_content_0

"The best memories are made around the table"

About Sicily Coal Fired Pizza

VILNAA0151T01.jpg

At Sicily, the drinks are just as memorable as the food. Explore over 50 rotating beers on tap, handcrafted seasonal cocktails, premium spirits, and Connecticut’s only restaurant offering 72 wines by the glass through a state-of-the-art Coravin preservation system.

Where the Bar Is Part of the Experience

site_index_parallax_6

Seasonal Cocktails, Local Drafts & Exceptional Wines

In The News

DSC02510.jpg

51bd034ebc5c4c50a7dea31014978de1 (1).jpg

site_index_parallaxslider_5

A Taste of What’s Happening

Big milestones deserve great food, great drinks, and a space designed for unforgettable celebrations. Sicily’s private event rooms are perfect for birthdays, bridal showers, rehearsal dinners, holiday parties, and everything in between.

Celebrate Big at Sicily

Start Planning

site_index_CenteredOverlaySection_4

The Perfect Space for Every Occasion

Sicily was created to bring great food, great drinks, and great company together under one roof. From the lively bar scene and entertainment lounge to intimate dinners and private celebrations, every space was designed to create an experience guests want to return to.

About Sicily

site_index_content_3

More Than a Restaurant

From handcrafted pastas and New Haven-style pizza to fresh seafood, steaks, charcuterie, and rotating seasonal features, Sicily’s menu blends Italian classics with elevated favorites made for every kind of night out.

DSC02638.jpg

View Our Menu

site_index_CenteredOverlaySection_2

From Coal Fired to Chef Crafted

site_index_video_1

Rooted in Tradition

Explore the Menu

DSC02554.jpg

site_index_hero_0

Coal Fired Pizza & Italian Hospitality Done the Sicily Way

Turn your nights upside down with our brand-new Reverse Happy Hour —because the best vibes start late. Beginning April 9th, join us every Thursday from 7PM to 12PM for unbeatable drink and food specials, high-energy ambiance, and live beats from DJ Amy Grey from Radio 104.1. Whether you’re winding down or just getting started, this is your go-to spot for great music, great company, and even better times. Grab your crew and experience happy hour the way it should be—after dark.

Press

In the Press

The Middletown Press

Tony & Maria's Dream come to life